What was the worst genocide in history, and how do we even begin to measure the depths of human atrocity that were perpetrated during such catastrophic events? Is it possible to accurately compare the extensive suffering endured by countless individuals across different periods and regions? When examining such a dark aspect of humanity, can we sift through the varying motivations, political contexts, and outcomes that define these tragic occurrences? Moreover, how do the narratives surrounding these genocides shape contemporary understanding and collective memory? The Holocaust, the Armenian Genocide, the Rwandan Genocide—each case is marked by profound loss and devastation. Yet, do they not also invite us to reflect on the broader implications of indifference and complicity in the face of such evil? In this complex tapestry of humanity’s past, what criteria should be employed to discern the most devastating acts of genocide? Can we truly arrive at a consensus on this harrowing question?